| I Frederic Dan Huntington | 1869-1904 | |
| II Charles Tyler Olmstead | Coadjutor 1902 | 1904-1921 |
| III Charles Fiske | Coadjutor 1915 | 1921-1936 |
| IV Edward Coley | Suffragan 1924 | 1936-1942 |
| V Malcolm Endicott Peabody | Coadjutor 1938 | 1942-1960 |
| VI Walter Maydole Higley (with Bishop Peabody) | Suffragan 1948 | 1960-1969 |
| VII Ned Cole | Coadjutor 1964 | 1969-1983 |
| VIII O'Kelley Whittaker | Coadjutor 1981 | 1983-1992 |
| IX David B. Joslin | Coadjutor 1991 | 1992-2000 |
